Study: New imaging technology shows promise in detecting of spread of prostate cancer
Contents
At a glance | Clinical trials |
Strengths and limitations | Questions for your doctor |
What does this mean for me? | Resources |
In-depth |
STUDIES AT A GLANCE
These studies are about:
How a new technology may be useful to detect spread of cancer in men with newly diagnosed disease or in those whose cancer returns after treatment.
Why are these studies important?
cancer is the second most diagnosed cancer in men. About seven percent of all cancers are in advanced stages (spread beyond the ) at the time of diagnosis.
After cancer diagnosis, healthcare providers often order a series of tests to the cancer. helps doctors determine how advanced the cancer is and whether it has spread beyond the gland. is used to make a treatment plan. Currently, doctors use standard imaging tests to prostate cancer, such as:
- X-rays
- magnetic resonance imaging ()
- computed tomography ()
- positron emission tomography ()
These tests can show if the cancer has spread to other organs. However, they sometimes do not detect spread of the disease.
PET/CT scans
PET/CT scans combine two types of imaging—PET scans (positron emission tomography) and CT scans (computerized tomography)—in one test. PET/CT requires injection of a small amount of a radioactive drug known as a tracer. After injection, the tracer spreads through the body. The PET/CT scanners detect areas in the body where high amounts of the tracer are found. This allows doctors to to look for cancers and see how tissues and organs are working.
Prostate cancer risk groups
Most cancer is found at an early . Most men with prostate cancer do well. However, some cancers, even those that are early , may be more aggressive and have a higher risk for metastasizing (spreading) to other parts of the body.
cancer (cancer that has spread to other organs) requires more aggressive treatment and can lead to death. Doctors use standard tests to group cancers by risk for recurrence and spread and use this information to guide treatment. The main risk goups include:
- low risk
- intermediate risk
- high risk
OSPREY and CONDOR studies
Two research studies, OSPREY and CONDOR, looked at a new radioactive tracer called “18FDCFPyL PSMA.”
18FDCFPyL PSMA was created to bind a protein called (PSMA). PSMA is found at low levels on normal cells, but it is found at high levels on cancer cells. Because PSMA is found on the outside of cells, it is being used by researchers to detect cancer and to develop treatments that directly target cancer cells.
These studies compared the 18FDCFPyL PSMA screening technology to standard imaging for cancer spread, which includes XRAY, and CT. The studies looked at two groups of men:
- men with newly diagnosed cancer
- men whose cancer returned after treatment
OSPREY study findings
The OSPRY study included 268 men with high-risk cancer.
All 268 participants had imaging with 18FDCFPyL PSMA.
- 18FDCFPyL PSMA was much better than standard imaging at detecting the spread of cancer in high-risk patients.
- 18FDCFPyL PSMA found cancer spread in 27% of men, compared with standard imaging, which found spread in less than 4% of men.
CONDOR study findings
The CONDOR study tested whether 18FDCFPyL PSMA was better at detecting cancer that returned after treatment compared to standard imaging.
The study included 208 men with cancer who were treated with androgen therapy (testosterone depleted) and received other treatments (prostatectomy, radiation therapy, etc.) for cancer. Blood tests given to men after treatment suggested a return of cancer but could not be confirmed by standard imaging.
During the CONDOR study, participants underwent imaging with 18FDCFPyL PSMA.
- Standard imaging did not detect return of cancer in any of the men (0 of 208 participants)
- 18FDCFPyL PSMA detected the return of cancer in about 66% of men (137 of 208 participants).
Side effects of 18FDCFPyL PSMA
Among the OSPREY and CONDOR studies, the most common side effects related to 18FDCFPyL PSMA tracer included:
- headache
- altered sense of taste (OSPREY)
- fatigue (CONDOR)
Strengths and limitations of the OSPREY and CONDOR studies
Strengths
- The large study sample size allowed researchers to determine if the technology works in multiple patients and to observe if side effects are associated with its use.
- For CONDOR, the sample population was restricted to men whose blood test suggested their cancer had returned, which suggests that the technology may be useful in detecting recurring cancer.
Limitations
- Despite finding more cancers that spread, the studies do not show that use of 18FDCFPyL PSMA to find cancer spread earlier improves outcomes such as survival.
- These research findings have not been published. The following limitations will likely be included in a publication:
- Researchers did not mention how much time elapsed between standard imaging and imaging with 18FDCFPyL PSMA. It is possible that the cancer may have been limited to the during standard imaging if much time had passed between the two procedures.
- The studies did not mention race/ethnicity among patients. Medical procedures may work better or worse for people of different races and ethnicities.
What does this mean for me?
In both studies, 18FDCFPyL PSMA detected more cases where cancer had spread beyond the when compared with standard imaging. For OSPREY, the technique found almost eight times more metastases (spread of cancer) than standard imaging. For CONDOR, the technique found cancer spread 62 times more than standard imaging.
18FDCFPyL PSMA is not FDA-approved for use outside of research studies, and the OSPREY and CONDOR trials are completed. However, other clinical trials looking at 18FDCFPyL PSMA as a technology to detect cancer are recruiting participants (see Clinical Trials below). If you are at high risk of developing advanced cancer, talk to your healthcare provider to see if you may be eligible for an ongoing clinical trial.
Share your thoughts on this XRAYS article by taking our brief survey.
Posted 10/16/20
References
Pouliot F, Carroll P, Probst S, et al. A Phase II/III Multicenter Study of PSMA-targeted 18F-DCFPyL PET/CT Imaging in Patients with Cancer (OSPREY): A Sub-Analysis of Regional and Distant Metastases Detection Rates at Initial by 18F-DCFPyL PET/CT. 2020 Genitourinary Cancers Symposium. ASCO20 Virtual Scientific Program. Abstract #9
Morris M, Caroll P, Saperstein L. Impact of PSMA-targeted imaging with 18F-DCFPyL-PET/CT on clinical management of patients (pts) with biochemically recurrent (BCR) cancer (PCa): Results from a phase III, , multicenter study (CONDOR). ASCO20 Virtual Scientific Program. Abstract #5501.
Disclosure
FORCE receives funding from industry sponsors, including companies that manufacture cancer drugs, tests and devices. All XRAYS articles are written independently of any sponsor and are reviewed by members of our Scientific Advisory Board prior to publication to assure scientific integrity.
This article is relevant for:
Men with high-risk prostate cancer
This article is also relevant for:
people with metastatic or advanced cancer
healthy people with average cancer risk
people with prostate cancer
people newly diagnosed with cancer
people with a genetic mutation linked to cancer risk
Be part of XRAY:
IN-DEPTH REVIEW OF RESEARCH
Study background:
While multiple imaging tests (e.g., X-rays, , CT or bone scans) are FDA-approved as diagnostics to view the spread of cancer, they are limited. Some imaging tests for cancer have been observed to miss the spread of the disease, while other techniques have detected abnormalities that are unrelated, resulting in “false positives.”
In the OSPREY and CONDOR clinical trials, researchers looked at 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT as a possible imaging diagnostic to better detect cancer and its spread to nearby organs compared with standard imaging.
18FDCFPyL PSMA uses positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) imaging, which uses a radioactive drug to detect levels of (PSMA). The PSMA protein is normally found at a low level in normal cells, but it is significantly increased in cancer cells. PSMA can be detected in other organs as cancer spreads.
If 18FDCFPyL PSMA is confirmed by future studies to better detect the spread of cancer to other organs, it could be a useful diagnostic for accurately the disease at initial diagnosis and relapse in men who were previously treated for the disease.
Researchers of the studies wanted to know:
If 18FDCFPyL PSMA can locate the spread of cancer in newly diagnosed men and in men whose cancer returned after treatment.
Study design and findings:
OSPREY
OSPREY was a phase 2 and 3 clinical trial that was held at 10 sites throughout the U.S. and Canada. The primary goal of the study was to test whether 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT could detect spread of cancer to pelvic (organs near the gland).
The study included 268 men, ranging from ages 46 to 84, with newly diagnosed high risk cancer. Of these, 252 men were candidates for radical prostatectomy (complete removal of the ). Prior to the study, all participants had standard imaging to detect (spread) of cancer.
During the study, participants were given 18FDCFPyL PSMA by injection. Two hours prior to PET/CT scans, patients were injected with radioactive 18FDCFPyL PSMA that specifically targets PSMA throughout the body. (Data from PET/CT scans were tabulated by three PET/CT readers who were blinded to all participant clinical information.)
Among all 268 participants:
- 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT detected cancer to nearby in 27% of men (72 of 268 participants), compared with standard imaging which detected spreading in about 4% of men.
- Of the 72 men with cancer, 39 had cancers that spread only to nearby , while the other 33 men had cancers that metastasized to distant and other organs.
Among the 252 men in the study who had surgery to remove their gland and nearby that could be looked at to confirm if the cancer had spread or not.
- standard imaging showed 244 of 252 (almost 97%) had no cancer spread.
- 18FDCFPyL PSMA detected cancer in a total of 56 out of 252 (22%) patients. This changed the of their disease.
Most common side effects related to 18FDCFPyL PSMA included:
- distorted sense of taste (dysgeusia)
- headache
Strength of study
- This study included a large sample size, which is needed to determine if the technology works in multiple patients and to observe if side effects are associated with its use.
Limitations of study
(Findings of this trial were presented at a meeting. Due to time constraints, presenters were not able to present all aspects of the study. Limitations listed below may be addressed in detail in a follow-up manuscript.)
- The study did not include a (control) group to control for false positives.
- Researchers did not mention how much time elapsed between standard imaging and imaging with 18FDCFPyL PSMA. It is possible that the cancer may have been limited to the during standard imaging if much time had passed between the two procedures.
- The trial did not distinguish between people with or without an . Some medical treatment/procedures have been known to work better in people with specific mutations.
- The study did not mention race/ethnicity among patients. Some races/ethnicities are more responsive to certain medical procedures than others.
CONDOR
CONDOR was a phase 3 multicenter clinical trial performed at 14 sites throughout the U.S. and Canada. The study’s primary endpoint was whether 18FDCFPyL PSMA has the capability to detect the return of cancer in men who were previously treatmented for the disease.
The study consisted of 208 participants between ages 43 to 91 who were treated with (testosterone deficient) and received treatment for a previous diagnosis for cancer by prostatectomy only, radiation therapy only, combined prostatectomy and radiation therapy, or other systematic therapy.
Blood tests were given to the men during posttreatment follow-ups. Increases in prostate-specific antigen () levels that were greater than two nanograms/milliliters suggested possible return of cancer. At the start of the study, patients underwent standard imaging and completed questionnaires about their plans to treat relapse.
During the trial, participants underwent imaging with 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT. They were injected with nine millicuries of the radioactive drug 18FDCFPyL PSMA one to two hours prior to having PET/CT scans.
The results showed that 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT was able to detect cancer relapse in about 62 percent of participants, whereas standard imaging methods did not detect any return of cancer among participants. Results of 18FDCFPyL PSMA scans led 64 percent of participants to change their plans to treat relapse.
The most common side effects related to 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT included:
- fatigue
- headache
Strengths of study
- The study included a large sample size, which is needed to determine if the technology works in multiple patients and to observe if side effects are associated with its use.
- The study included only men whose blood analysis suggested relapse of cancer.
Limitations of study
(Findings of this trial were presented at a meeting. Due to time constraints, presenters were not able to present all aspects of the study. Limitations listed below may be addressed in detail in a follow up manuscript.)
- The study did not include a (control) group to control for false positives.
- No information was given about which standard imaging procedures were used in the study. This is critical to make a fair comparison between 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT imaging and a specific standard imaging technology.
- The trial did not distinguish between people with or without inherited mutations. Some medical treatment/procedures have been known to work better in people with specific mutations.
- The study did not mention race/ethnicity among patients. Some medical procedures may work better or worse for people of different races and ethnicities.
Context:
Detecting the spread of cancer to other organs is necessary to accurately and determine the severity of the disease. More accurate can help men make better decisions on treatment options for cancer. Based on the studies’ findings, 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT detected almost eight times more metastases among OSPREY participants and 62 times more cancer among CONDOR participants when compared with standard imaging. These data suggest that newer diagnostics are needed to improve the standard processes for and detecting the spread of cancer.
Conclusions:
OSPREY and CONDOR clinical trials looked at the capability of 18FDCFPyL PSMA PET/CT to detect cancer in newly diagnosed men and in castrated men who relapsed after cancer treatment. If confirmed in future studies, imaging techniques that detect the increase and spread of PSMA using PET/CT scans could be better methods to determine and of cancer compared with standard imaging.
Posted 10/16/20
- What is the best way to tell if my cancer has spread?
- What tests have already been done?
- What were the results of these tests?
- What, if any, additional testing should I have?
- Do these tests have any side effects?
- Is my cancer low, intermediate or high risk?
- How will these tests affect my medical options?
- Can you provide a copy of my test results?
- Should I consider a clinical trial?
The following are studies looking at new methods for , monitoring and finding recurrence in people with cancer.
- NCT02282137: 68Ga-PSMA PET-CT Scan for Diagnosis and Management of Cancer (PSMA). This study looks at the effectiveness of the 68Ga-PSMA-11 PET-CT scan to detect tumor location and measure size in patients with suspected or confirmed cancer or cancer that may have come back.
- NCT04030338: (PSMA) PET Scans to Find Cancer. This study will determine whether PET scans using PSMA are accurate and more effectively find cancer than the standard methods.
- NCT04716725: 68Ga-PSMA-11 PET for the Diagnosis of Castration Resistant Cancer. This trial assesses whether using 68Ga-PSMA-11 PET scans will help doctors learn more about the location of disease in the body.
- NCT04777071: An Investigational Scan (68Ga-PSMA-11 PET/CT) for the Imaging of Cancer. This trial studies how well 68Ga-PSMA-11 PET/CT scans work for imaging patients with cancer.
- NCT04867603: Digital PET/CT Using [Ga-68]PSMA for Characterization of Lesions. This study evaluates a radioactive diagnostic drug called Gallium-68 Specific Membrane Antigen ([Ga-68]PSMA) to determine whether abnormalities are cancer.
- NCT05160597: Image-Guided (68Ga-PSMA-11 PET/CT) Biopsy for the Diagnosis of Cancer in Men With Prior Negative/Inconclusive Biopsy. This study looks at how well an image-guided biopsy using the imaging agent 68Ga-prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSMA)-11 with a PET/CT scan works in diagnosing cancer in men with a prior negative or inconclusive biopsy.
Several other clinical trials for monitoring patients with cancer can be found here.
Updated: 05/29/2023
The following organizations offer peer support services for people with or at high risk for cancer:
- FORCE peer support
- Visit our message boards.
- Once you register, you can post on the Diagnosed With Cancer board to connect with other people who have been diagnosed.
- Sign up for our Peer Navigation Program.
- Users are matched with a volunteer who shares their mutation and situation.
- Join our private Facebook group.
- Find a virtual or in-person support meeting.
- Join a Zoom community group meeting.
- Visit our message boards.
- ZERO-The End of Cancer is a nonprofit organization that provides information and support resources for men with cancer.
Updated: 03/08/2023
Who covered this study?
Targeted Oncology
PyL PET tracer may be superior to standard imaging for prostate cancer This article rates 2.0 out of 5 stars
ASCO Post
In biochemically recurrent prostate cancer, PSMA-Targeted PET/CT imaging may be useful This article rates 4.0 out of 5 stars
UroToday
ASCO GU 2020: PSMA-targeted 18F-DCFPyL PET/CT imaging in patients with prostate cancer (OSPREY) This article rates 4.0 out of 5 stars
MedPage Today
PET spots prostate cancer mets missed on CT, MRI This article rates 5.0 out of 5 stars