The FORCE Blog
Our blog features information and personal perspectives on topics of interest to the hereditary cancer community.
Education > Our Blog > Headline Hype: BRCA and Risk of Dying from Cancer
Headline Hype: BRCA and Risk of Dying from Cancer

January 13, 2018

Headline Hype: BRCA and Risk of Dying from Cancer

by Piri Welcsh, PhD

An article published in Newsweek with the incredibly misleading title “A Gene That 'Causes Cancer' Probably Doesn’t Increase Your Chances of Dying from Cancer” created quite a social media stir.  This media story, and the research that it reports on, was the subject of this XRAY review. We developed XRAY to help our constituents look beyond the hype, to understand media reports on breast cancer research. Since each of our XRAY reviews take several weeks to research, write, score, summarize, edit and undergo Advisory Board review before it is published, and our publication calendar for the next month is packed with prior studies, we wanted to respond rapidly to the most alarming aspects of this headline.

The Newsweek article refers to new research published in Lancet Oncology. The researchers studied young women with breast cancer, comparing those who had a BRCA mutation to those who did not, to see if mutation status affected survival. The results of this new research suggest that there is not significant difference in overall survival between these two groups. In other words, in people already diagnosed with breast cancer, having a BRCA mutation did not change prognosis.

This is a very different conclusion than the one suggested by the headlines. In the case of prostate cancer, for example, studies have shown that among men with prostate cancer, those with a BRCA mutation (and possibly other mutations) are more likely to develop aggressive disease than prostate cancer survivors without a mutation.

Further, without any intervention, people with BRCA mutations are at higher risk of dying from aggressive cancers like ovarian cancer than people in the general population.

This is the first of a new FORCE blog series, “Headline Hype," which will be linked to our XRAY Program. XRAY provides weekly summaries of research articles on breast cancer covered by the media. One of our goals with XRAY is to help people become discerning consumers of health media.

We will cover this topic and article in more depth in a future XRAY. Stay tuned.

Posted in: XRAY
Tags: BRCA , BRCA1


January 17, 2018

Headline Hype: Why You Can't Believe Everything You Read - Facing Our Risk of Cancer Empowered - Facing Our Risk of Cancer Empowered says:
[…] Headline Hype: BRCA and Risk of Dying from Cancer […]


January 13, 2018

Marilyn Welcsh says:
Thanks daughter. Good article. Mom


January 13, 2018

Frank Poynter says:
Thank you for helping to keep the media honest in their health care reporting.


Leave a Reply