Kids' response to test results
How Children Respond to a Parent’s BRCA Test Results
by Tracy M. Diaz
After testing positive for a BRCA mutation, experts recommend that people communicate their results to adult family members. Facing hereditary cancer, undergoing genetic testing, and pursuing risk management options can be a stressful process for entire families, especially when young children are involved. Although experts recommend against genetic testing of minors, children are frequently aware of the serious and inherited nature of cancer in their families.
Dr. Angela Bradbury at Fox Chase Cancer Center studied how children respond when told of a parent’s mutation status. In her study, a total of 253 parents participated in a telephone interview. All participants received genetic counseling before and after their BRCA testing, which occurred while they had at least one child under the age of 25. Their test results were categorized as either true negative (6% of participants), true positive (29% of participants), uninformative negative (57% of participants), or a variant of undetermined significance (VUS) (9% of participants). True negative refers to individuals who tested negative for a known mutation identified in the family, while uninformative negative refers to participants who tested negative and belong to families without a known mutation. VUS refers to an identified gene change with an unknown effect on cancer risk.
Most parents (84%) informed their children within one month of learning their test result. The majority of children over 14 years old were informed, while about half of children between ages 10 and 13 were informed. When children heard the test results, most of their reactions were neutral (41%) or relieved (28%). Those who expressed relief and happiness (28%) had been told of a parent’s negative result. A smaller percentage of children felt concern (13%) or distress (11%)—distress was more common when results were positive or VUS. Some parents reported that children did not understand the information (7%), asked questions or seemed curious (5%), and/or appreciated the information and found it useful (4%).
How Children Respond Reference
Bradbury AR, Patrick-Miller L, Egleston BL, et al. “When parents disclose BRCA1/2 test results: Their communication and perceptions of offspring response.” Cancer, January 9, 2012. Epublished ahead of print.
This is the largest study to explore communication of BRCA test results between parents and their children. The study found that most parents share results with their children, and that the majority of children do not find this information distressing. Other findings include:
- Parents were more likely to communicate results when their tests were negative, when they had daughters, and when they had older children.
- Parents were more likely to share negative test results and less likely to share positive results with their daughters.
- Parents more often shared negative test results with daughters than with sons. This difference was not seen in parents who had a positive result.
- Children were most often concerned about a parent’s positive test result.
- Children who were distressed or didn’t understand results were most often younger than age 10. Concern was more common in children between ages 14 and 24.
- Neutral responses were mostly reported in sons, while distress and finding the information useful was mostly reported in daughters.
Tracy M. Diaz is a doctoral graduate student in the Cancer Biology program at UT Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas, TX. She researches cancer vaccines and enjoys doing volunteer work in her free time. She is also a BRCA2 mutation carrier.
Disclaimer: Health links are made available for educational purposes only. This information should not be interpreted as medical advice. All health information should be discussed with your health care provider. Please read our full disclaimer for more information.
This site has been made possible by a generous grant from Morphotek.