FORCE’s eXamining the Relevance of Articles for Young Survivors (XRAYS) program is a reliable resource for breast cancer research-related news and information. XRAYS reviews new breast cancer research, provides plain-language summaries, and rates how the media covered the topic. XRAYS is funded by the CDC.
Breast cancer survivors
Women under 45
Women over 45
Men with breast cancer
Metastatic breast cancer
Triple negative breast cancer
BRCA mutation carriers
Her2+ breast cancer
Special populations: Women at high risk for breast cancer
Many treatments that lower estrogen levels also reduce breast cancer risk. Unfortunately, these treatments are also associated with negative side effects. A recent study looked at the effect of regular aerobic exercise on the estrogen levels of women who are at high risk for breast cancer.
How aerobic exercise affects estrogen levels in young women who are at high risk for breast cancer.
Removing the ovaries and taking risk-reducing medications such as tamoxifen have been shown to reduce breast cancer risk; however, both are associated with short-term and long-term side effects. Aerobic exercise does not have negative long-term consequences, and is an accessible activity for people, so understanding if exercise can also lower estrogen levels is the first step in determining whether or not it can be used to reduce breast cancer risk in young women who are at high risk for breast cancer.
This study looked only at the effect of exercise on estrogen levels in premenopausal women at high risk for breast cancer—it did not directly measure the effect on breast cancer risk. Researchers found that exercise was associated with lower estrogen levels, which may reduce breast cancer risk. This is most likely to be relevant only in women whose cancer cells use estrogen receptors (ER), allowing estrogen to spur the growth of ER-positive breast cancer. Many high-risk women, including those with BRCA1 mutations, develop triple-negative breast cancer, which does not utilize the estrogen receptor; this suggests estrogen levels might not be as relevant for these women.
Regardless of its effect on breast cancer risk, exercise is extremely beneficial for many aspects of health: it helps to control weight; prevent heart disease, diabetes and high blood pressure; boosts energy; and improves mood and sleep. Everyone is encouraged to talk with their health care providers about how they can make exercise part of their routine. Women at high risk for breast cancer should continue to maintain a heightened breast cancer screening schedule with their health care provider even when engaging in an exercise program.
Some types of cancer need the hormone estrogen to grow. Because of this, many breast cancer treatments and risk management strategies focus on reducing estrogen levels. Past studies have shown that BRCA mutation carriers who reported exercising during adolescence had lower breast cancer risk or a delayed breast cancer diagnosis, suggesting that there might be a relationship between exercise and breast cancer risk. Dr. Kathryn Schmidt and colleagues at University of Pennsylvania investigated whether or not exercise could affect estrogen levels in women at high risk for breast cancer. Rather than ask women how often they exercised, this study measured women’s estrogen levels before they began an exercise program, and again 5 months after they participated in a monitored aerobic exercise program.
How exercise affects estrogen levels in premenopausal women at high risk for breast cancer.
The study included 135 women, who at the start of the study:
Women were followed over 7 menstrual cycles, with the first 2 months used to establish their normal estrogen levels, and the final 5 months used to monitor changes in their estrogen levels when they participated in a prescribed aerobic exercise regimen. Women were placed into one of three groups:
Hormone levels naturally change during different phases of the menstrual cycle. When researchers followed the women’s hormone levels at different stages of their menstrual cycle, they found that:
This was a relatively small study of women who were all at high risk for breast cancer. Further studies would be needed to compare the results in young women with average breast cancer risk.The study followed women for 5 months, so whether the reduction in estrogen levels seen would be maintained is unknown.
In addition, the short study period could only follow reduction in estrogen levels; women would need to be followed for a longer time to show that this reduction in estrogen levels is directly associated with a lower breast cancer risk. This was the most crucial limitation of the study—investigators looked at estrogen levels, yet changes in estrogen levels may not result in any change in breast cancer risk.
The results of this study show that exercise reduces estrogen levels, meaning that it might perhaps reduce risk of breast cancer, particularly in women who have the estrogen receptor (ER+). While the study was small, exercise is beneficial for many aspects of health other than cancer, and that is why all everyone is encouraged to discuss the best way to incorporate exercise into their regular routines.
While a reduction in estrogen might reduce the risk of breast cancer developing, it is not yet a certainty. Patients should talk with their health care providers about all the methods they should be using to reduce their risk of developing cancer. In this study, exercise did not lower estrogen levels as much as removing ovaries or taking medications such as tamoxifen or raloxifene. Additionally, medications have been tested in randomized clinical trials and demonstrated to reduce breast cancer risk, whereas exercise has not. Women at high risk for breast cancer are encouraged to discuss national guidelines that outline risk management for people at high risk for breast cancer with their health care providers and maintain a regular schedule of breast cancer screening.
Schmitz KH, Williams NI, Kontos D, et al. “Dose-response effects of aerobic exercise on estrogen among women at high risk for breast cancer: a randomized controlled trial.” Breast Cancer Research and Treatment. Published first online on October 28, 2015.